The end of the year of course means Top 10 lists! Here are my ten favorite films of 2024 (and four honorable mentions). Oscar nominations follow in just a few weeks, on Friday, January 17th. Stay tuned to see if Oscar voters share my thinking. And be sure to also check out fellow SP Film Critic Chad’s Top 20 list here. In the meantime–see you back in the cinema in 2025!
Mangold, Chalamet create a biopic worth a watch—and a listen
Bob Dylan (Timothée Chalamet) arrives in New York from Minnesota.
Writer/director James Mangold is no stranger to a music biopic. In 2006, Reese Witherspoon won a Best Actress Oscar for playing June Cash in Mangold’s Johnny Cash biopic Walk the Line. The movie garnered four other nominations, including a nomination for Joaquin Phoenix’s portrayal of Cash. Now, 18 years later, don’t be surprised if A Complete Unknown, Mangold’s dramatization of Bob Dylan’s rise to fame, yields similar awards for its exceptional cast.
Eggers takes Nosferatu for a chilling, seductive spin
In his films, Robert Eggers (The Witch, The Lighthouse, The Northman) loves to explore ancient rituals and antiquated language. Remaking Nosferatu, director F.W. Murnau’s 1922 German silent film based on Bram Stoker’s Dracula, seemed like a perfect fit due to the story’s gothic style, devilish rituals, and old-fashioned dialect. Eggers’ Nosferatu is a darkly seductive version of the classic horror story, with enough theatricality to make it the director’s most widely accessible film to date.Continue reading “Film Review: “Nosferatu””
Kidman and Dickinson play with power dynamics in Babygirl
In case anyone doubts her, Nicole Kidman remains one of the most talented movie stars, still working, and proves it again in Babygirl. Kidman exists among a tiny group of actors who can effortlessly disappear into their diverse set of challenging roles. Babygirl represents another winning entry in her extensive filmography, which is a monumental testament to the longevity of her acting prowess. Babygirl is writer/director Halina Reijn’s follow-up to her comedy horror sleeper hit, Bodies Bodies Bodies. On the surface, the two films have very little in common, but within their respective stories is an incisive exploration of power dynamics and modern concepts of gender roles.Continue reading “Film Review: “Babygirl””
Mufasa is a princely improvement, but still no match for the original King
The 2019 photorealistic remake of the 1994 classic The Lion King was a global box office sensation, but lacked the joy, energy, and instantly-memorable character portrayals of the original. When Oscar winner Barry Jenkins (Moonlight) announced he’d be directing a follow-up to the 2019 film, the choice seemed a peculiar one for the accomplished filmmaker. Upon watching Mufasa: The Lion King, however, we can clearly see (and feel) that Jenkins cared passionately about the thematic elements of the proposed prequel. Combined with original songs by Lin-Manuel Miranda and improved character designs, Mufasa: The Lion King is a superior follow-up to the 2019 film, even if it still fails to break new ground in any meaningful way.Continue reading “Film Review: “Mufasa: The Lion King””
The Brutalist is a towering achievement in epic visual storytelling
Ten thousand words could be written about the surreal, dizzying shot of an upside-down Statue of Liberty in The Brutalist, Brady Corbet’s epic tale of a Hungarian immigrant’s experience in America. The Statue of Liberty sequence lasts no more than twenty seconds, yet a skewed opinion of a burgeoning nation’s dreams, hopes, and promises lie within its symbolism. The Brutalist is filled with amazing imagery like the Statue of Liberty shot, and monumental performances to match them. With The Brutalist, from its musical score to its costuming, Corbet has assembled a modern masterpiece, a staggering filmmaking achievement that weaves together the majesty and tragedy of the American Dream into a captivating and intimate story.Continue reading “Film Review: “The Brutalist””
Nightbitch is a reductive maternal fable stretched thin
Being a mother is difficult. While I can’t personally attest to the difficulties of motherhood, I understand that to be objectively true. I’ve also seen many films across multiple genres that tackle the hardships of motherhood, from Freaky Friday to The Babadook. Many of these films depict how maternal hardships can be understood on deeper levels, or seen from a previously unexplored perspective. Facing the demands of motherhood, and depending on the genre, protagonists go on a journey of self-discovery through side-splitting humor, terrorizing horror, or tear-jerking drama. Nightbitch is a dark comedy that focuses so resolutely on the most fundamental difficulties of being a parent – losing sleep, social and professional sacrifices, too much to do and not enough time to do it – that the film’s creative supporting elements fail to make an impact.Continue reading “Film Review: “Nightbitch””
Guadagnino’s soul-searching adaptation is a mixed bag of moods
If you’re familiar with the literary works of William S. Burroughs, then perhaps you won’t be surprised that film adaptations of his novels contain a strong sense of surreality, auto-biographicality, and intense intimacy. The latter characteristic is also prevalently featured in the works of director Luca Guadagnino (Call Me By Your Name; Challengers). Despite Guadagnino and Burroughs’ shared love for portraying romantic physicality, and Daniel Craig’s impressively daring and vulnerable performance, Guadagnino’s adaptation of the Burroughs short novel, Queer, tries and often fails to properly balance the two artists’ stylistic approaches.Continue reading “Film Review: “Queer””
Hoult and Law bolster The Order’sthrilling real-world drama
This has been a monumental year for Nicholas Hoult. He has starred in four films: The Garfield Movie, Juror #2, The Order, and the upcoming Nosferatu. It’s difficult to envision a wider-range of films for an actor in one year, and The Order may be his most consequential role. In The Order, Hoult shares the spotlight with Jude Law, who is also playing against type. The film follows a series of real-life events that took place in the Pacific Northwest in the 1980s, with themes that continue to be relevant given the U.S.’s turbulent state of current political affairs. Procedural and moody, The Order avoids preachiness in favor of character exploration and thrilling action set pieces.Continue reading “Film Review: “The Order””
Elphaba (Cynthia Erivo, l.) and Galinda (Ariana Grande) become friends after a rocky start.
There are three main things you need to know if you’re considering seeing Wicked, the cinematic adaptation of the award-winning Broadway musical. First: Be aware that it’s very long–almost three hours. Second: Most of the movie posters for the film haven’t emphasized this fact–and only recently did IMDB change the film’s title from just Wicked to Wicked: Part I–but the film that opens today is indeed only PART ONE of a two-part adaptation. The movie released today corresponds to the live musical’s first act. That means that somehow the production’s entire story–which managed to be told in a nearly three hour live musical (including an intermission, no less)–has, in the hands of director John M. Chu (Crazy Rich Asians; In the Heights), become an interminable six hour filmic experience, with the two individual movies running just as long as the original musical itself, while each only telling half the story. Which brings us to point three: While the film is a visual feast, featuring exceptional production design and cinematography, its stretched-out story drags, meanders, and is often mind numbingly dull.